Milwaukee Wedding Cakes & Dessert Bars: Planning Your Perfect Sweet Display

Wedding cakes can be artistic masterpieces with different shapes, sizes, accents, and of course, decadent flavors and icing options! Today’s couples also often create dessert stations by adding other tasty sweets and treats while still allowing the wedding cake to be a gorgeous focal point. Talk with your baker and designer to craft the perfect cake and desserts that complement your color palette, taste preferences, and vibe!

While a traditional table display can be beautiful, explore unique rental pieces and shelving options that will be a statement in your overall design and tie in with the style of your day. Stationers can also adorn your dessert area with creative signage, labels, and personalized cake toppers. Consult your florist about adding blooms or greens to create your desired look.

Details to Consider

SERVING SIZE
Cake and desserts are typically priced per serving, so know how many people you need to serve.

CAKE SHAPE
Come with ideas, and let your cake designer be creative with an edible masterpiece!

FLAVORS & FILLINGS
Schedule tastings with local bakers to help you decide on a flavor you love or learn about popular choices.

FROSTING
There are many options to ask about and explore—buttercream, whipped cream, rolled fondant, and more!

DECORATIONS
Consider additional accents such as floral, greenery, cake jewelry, ribbon, hand-paintings, a special cake topper, or other décor for the entire display.

STANDS
Buying or renting a cake stand or dessert trays can add elegance and uniqueness to your display.

Tiffany Christina Photography

What to Ask

  • Ask if they are licensed.
  • Ask about their cake and dessert options.
  • Ask who can attend tastings and if fees are involved.
  • Ask how far in advance they make the desserts.
  • Ask about vegan and gluten-free options or
    other dietary restrictions.
  • Ask if there are any additional fees for
    delivery and setup.
  • Ask if they offer cake or dessert stands, trays,
    or other displays, and when they would need to be returned if you use them.
  • Ask if they will work with your florist to add
    blooms or greens to your cake or desserts.
  • Ask if they will provide cake knives if you do not have a set you wish to use already.

Details to Know

  • Know if you are serving everyone cake or just
    having a cutting-cake for the two of you.
  • Know your guest count.
  • Know if you want any flowers, greens, or décor pieces added to the cake or dessert display.
  • Know if there are any cultural treats or
    meaningful desserts you wish to include.
  • Know how many different dessert options
    you want to offer.
  • Know if you are including any unique guest
    experiences, like an ice cream bar, s’mores
    station, cotton candy cart, etc.

Things to Remember

  • Remember to bring your own cake knives if you want to use a specific set.
  • Remember to discuss freezing the top layer of your cake for your first anniversary.
  • Remember to include signage for labeling and informing your guests about the desserts or unique experiences.
  • Remember to book your baker early if your
    wedding is during peak time or if they are popular.

Timing

6-12 MONTHS BEFORE:
Contact bakers to discuss ideas
and set up a tasting. 

6 MONTHS BEFORE:
Design Consultation
Discuss choices and flavors.

2 MONTHS BEFORE:
Final design tweaks

2-3 WEEKS BEFORE:
Verify details and final guest count.

Gratuity

Tips for the baker of your wedding cake usually go to the cake designer and may be shared with the baking staff. While not expected, this extra gesture can be included in the final payment, given on the day of, or delivered after the wedding. Since you might not interact with the baker on your wedding day, as you’ll probably be preparing during the cake delivery, consider designating a trusted guest or staff member to manage the tip. A thank-you note with an enclosed gift for your baker can also be left on your cake or dessert table before setup. Expressing your satisfaction with a great review is also appreciated.

Alex Rodriquez Photography | Allexx B Photography | Ampersand Photography | Anna Page Photography | Caroline Cavalcante Photography | Chelsea Matson Photography | Claire Neville Photography | Corinna Nicole Photography | Evenement Planning | Makayla Mashlan Photography | Makena Lee Photography | McNiel Photography | O&B Photo Co. | Reminisce Photography | Steve White Films | The McCartney’s Photography | Tiffany Christina Photography

Trending Desserts

While a classic wedding cake is a timeless centerpiece, many couples are adding variety to their dessert table with sweet treats that guests can easily grab and enjoy. Offering multiple dessert options can add personality to your reception, accommodate different tastes, and create a fun, interactive display. Here are some of our favorite ideas:

  • Cookies, donuts or donut walls
  • Mini dessert cups
  • Chocolate-covered pretzels
  • Macarons
  • Pie or mini hand pies
  • Marshmallows (or s’mores!)
  • Cannoli
  • Candy bar or candy buffet
  • Chocolate fountain
  • Rice Krispie treats
  • Cupcakes
  • Ice cream or ice cream bars
  • Cotton candy
  • Churros
  • Mini tarts
  • Pudding cups
  • Chocolate-covered strawberries/fruit
  • Baklava

Alex Rodriquez Photography | Ampersand Photography | Ashton Gonnering Photography | Caroline Cavalcante Photography | Dani Stephenson Photography | Heather Cook Elliott Photography | Liz Seonbuchner Photography | Makena Lee Photography | O&B Photo Co. | Rachel Nicole Photography LLC | The Keel Collective | Tiffany Christina Photography | Wilk Media

As you continue mapping out your big day, keep exploring the WedPlan advice section for helpful planning guides, expert tips, and checklists to support you every step of the way. When you’re ready for more ideas, head over to our inspiration section or real weddings for creative details from couples and vendors throughout the region.

WedPlan Vendors

The below wedding vendors are part of the WedPlan preferred vendor directory. View their portfolios and websites to learn more, and tell them you found them on wedplanmilwaukee.com.

Event Credits

Cakes & DessertsCowboy David's Bakery
Cakes & DessertsGreige Patisserie